- Introduction
- Flow
- Infection prevention and control
- Reduced patients in emergency departments
- Staffing
- Treatment
- Appendices
Aim
Emergency departments need to focus on the critically unwell or injured patients who need rapid assessment and interventions.
Background
Each year emergency departments have been seeing an increase in the number of patients attending. Demand is exceeding capacity. Patients are being cared for in inappropriate areas. And there are delays to assessment and treatment. For safe and effective care this must not continue. The need to reduce the number of patients attending the department is even more important to protect all patients.
Local areas have put in place systems to reduce attendances before the patient reaches the emergency department. Through our work, we have seen:
- actively encouraging patients to ‘talk first’ via GP practice or NHS 111
- active engagement of patients with GP and other support services
- primary care and secondary care coming together to make sure patient needs are being met
- review, support and investment in community services
- engagement and feedback with NHS 111 services to improve referrals
- support for local ambulance crews with ‘hear and treat’ or ‘see and treat’
- trusts providing links and support to pre-hospital systems - for example NHS 111, GP practices and care homes
- a move away from the patient coming to secondary care with more services moving into the community
- dedicated services to support specific patient population needs - such as community falls teams and admission avoidance schemes.
The system work needs to include liaison with the ambulance service to:
- make sure they bypass the emergency department so patients access the correct place first time - direct pathways to plastics, vascular, and ear nose and throat specialities
- reduce attendances for patients both self-presenting and arriving via ambulance - by supporting ‘see and treat’ and ‘hear and treat’, and keeping patients well in the community
- offer alternative pathways to crews - helplines, specialty clinics, same day emergency care, early pregnancy assessment units, and delivery suites.
In good emergency departments we have seen
Effective redirection and streaming systems in place so that patients can be safely streamed to the following by a senior led team:
- external to the trust
- self-care
- pharmacy
- NHS 111
- GP and primary care services
- community services
- urgent treatment centre (if external)
- mental health services (if external)
- internal to the trust
- urgent treatment centre if internal
- emergency pregnancy services
- delivery suite
- same day emergency care
- mental health services (if internal).
The emergency department and specialty teams have an agreement, with medical director support. Patients are taken to the ‘best team to see’ after their initial review. There’s an expectation that:
- a patient known to a service will be directly seen by that specialty team
- a patient with a complication from a procedure will be directly seen by that team
- a patient assessed by the emergency department team as needing specialty assessment is accepted directly by that team and reviewed in a timely fashion.
The specialty teams should have time scheduled to make sure this is feasible. They should provide feedback on outcomes to the emergency department. Particularly if the patient could have better served by another specialty team. The specialty team refers the patient on if needed. Specialty teams must be open to receiving referrals from each other as well as from the emergency department.
For the trust to actively support and encourage patient and staff behavioural change:
- encouraging patients to call GPs or NHS 111 first
- using coordinators within emergency departments and GPs to make sure patients have a GP - and support them through the registration process
- at the point of discharge from hospital, advising patients how to get help if needed and to only ‘go to A&E’ in an emergency.
To link with local primary care clinicians to encourage:
- good communication and support networks between primary and secondary care - such as dedicated helplines - secondary care consultants advise GPs how to avoid hospital attendances and admissions
- GPs to ‘call before they send’ patients to ensure the patient is seeing the right specialty first time.
Specialty teams should make sure their patients do not attend the emergency department when possible. For example, for post-operative complications.
To develop pathways for specific groups of patients whose needs may best be met elsewhere
- percutaneous endoscopic gastrostomy (PEG) tube problems
- catheter problems
- peripherally inserted central catheter (PICC) line problems.
Specific to reducing demand for emergency care from those children and young people who attend more frequently, we have seen:
- joint working with local hospital at home teams, so nurses can deliver ‘emergency department care’ at home
- developing education packages for children with long-term illnesses - highlighting pathways to access appropriate care when unwell or community review by specialist community nursing teams
- health visitors, school nurses and GPs providing education packages to families with young children who frequently attend emergency departments
- consultant paediatricians in GP hubs in the community
- remote access to specialist advice for parents, carers and GPs - avoids delayed presentations of children and young people needing urgent care
- local public information campaigns clarifying when and where to seek help.
- Specialty team agreement. An agreement drawn up and signed by all clinical leads and the medical director. Specialty teams accept, see and treat patients from streaming or assessment. This happens when the emergency department feels the patient is best suited to that team. There should be no need for emergency department junior staff to review these patients first.
- Primary care access. All GP practices have daily allocated slots for urgent cases. These can be used by the patients, NHS 111 or the hospitals. Much of the work is completed via telephone triage and consultations. Face-to-face slots are also available. Slots are available at the appropriate time so they can be accessed in a timely fashion.
- Non-clinical navigators. Non-clinical staff are based within the emergency department. They actively support the streaming and redirection team. The staff make sure the patient is seen in the correct place at the right time. For example, a dressing clinic or GP appointment. They also help patients to register with a GP practice while waiting with the emergency department/urgent treatment centre. This reduces the number of unregistered patients within the local community. And it encourages patients to use their GP first - for next time.
- Direct access. NHS 111, 999 and emergency department all have direct access to alternative care pathways. This could be ambulatory care, early pregnancy assessment units, urgent treatment centre. It’s important for all the providers to make sure patients go along the correctalternative care pathways. Demand and capacity must be mapped alongside a regular review of referral quality.
Clinical and executive feedback from the workshops we held in 2021
Suggested processes and ideas for improving patient safety
Changes to the NHS 111 service
Rethink clinical validation from inside NHS 111. For example, is it possible for all potential referrals to ED to be reviewed by a clinician, with ICS able to see the assessments? Workshop attendees felt this could potentially reduce the number of unnecessary referrals to EDs from the service.
Promote system-wide collaboration and continuous learning
Workshop attendees supported the introduction of direct admission rights for ED senior decision makers. This enables safer and swifter transfer of patients to appropriate specialty admission units, as well as alternative pathways.
The need to promote system-wide collaboration and continuous learning was also emphasised. This aims to refine safety processes while iteratively improving patient pathways.
ED patients streamed to same day emergency care (SDEC), inpatient (specialty by specialty) or urgent treatment centres (UTCs)
There is evidence of a large increase in emergency attendances over the past two decades. This is partly due to a larger and ageing population. But workshop attendees also felt that emergency admission is not always the best pathway for some patients. Many could be more appropriately treated in a non-urgent setting.
To assess this, you could monitor daily levels of Same Day Emergency Care (SDEC) activity, from both ED and Primary Care.
Examples of good practice
Regional level real-time risk assessment
Attendees supported the use of regional level system risk assessment tools or apps that work in real time.
An agreed set of associated actions and responsibilities can be triggered from this data. These actions could then be filtered to the appropriate services.
Example datasets that can drive possible safety improvements
- Admission conversion rates
- Admission conversion rates are a measure of:
- the acuity of the department
- decision making
- processes downstream.
- This enables you judge acuity levels and make evidence-based decisions. It will help with short and long-term planning, also with education.
- Admission conversion rates are a measure of:
- Re-attendance rates to ED
- HES data indicates there were 1.39 million re-attendances to emergency departments in 2020-21. This is equal to 10.4% of all unplanned attendances in England.
- Tracking re-attendance rate data will highlight recurring issues and identify potential causes. This enables evidence-based decision making to decrease re-attendance rates and improve patient safety.
- Proportion of patients clinically assessed and directed to same day emergency care (current vs aim)
- Proportion of patients clinically assessed and directed to another service off-site (for example urgent primary care/urgent treatment centres) or on-site (co-located urgent treatment centre, specialty assessment units, clinics)
- Proportion of patients sent to the emergency department by GP or other community provider without prior communication.
Next:
Staffing
Version history
Updated September 2023
We updated references to infection control procedures that have changed since the height of the COVID-19 pandemic. We also updated other minor references to the pandemic.
Updated October 2021
We held two workshops in 2021 for emergency clinicians and NHS executives. We added suggestions and good practice examples from those events. These updates refer more specifically to the pandemic.
Download and print
Listen
Podcast: Emergency departments responding to COVID-19 - Reduced demand, improved capacity
References
Rebuilding the NHS - RCP priorities for the resetting of services
Directory of Ambulatory Emergency Care for Adults
Improvement toolkit
Produced by front line clinicians in response to CQC’s Patient FIRST, this toolkit suggests a framework that NHS trusts can use to monitor and assess their progress in applying good practice principles.
This file may not be suitable for users of assistive technology.
If you use assistive technology and need a copy of this document in an alternative format, email webteam@cqc.org.uk. Let us know what format you need.